Tony's Pizza

Located in the heart of San Marino, Tony's Pizza stands as a beloved pillar of Italian cuisine, offering a true taste of tradition blended with exceptional quality. With over four decades of history, this pizza restaurant has perfected the art of crafting thin-crust pizzas that deliver a buttery, melt-in-your-mouth experience with each bite. Whether you're craving the smoky tang of a BBQ Chicken Pizza, the robust flavors of a Large Sausage Mushroom, or the zesty freshness found in their Caprese Salad, Tony's menu promises to engage your senses and satisfy your Italian food cravings.

Beyond their iconic pizzas, Tony's Pizza serves a variety of pasta dishes that boast authentic, comforting flavors — from creamy Fettuccini Alfredo and vibrant Penne Pesto to the hearty, homemade taste of Meat Lasagna and baked ziti that showcases classic Italian soulfulness. For those seeking lighter fare or a quick bite, their cold sandwiches range from Ham & Cheese to the specially crafted Tony's Special, each thoughtfully prepared with fresh ingredients and robust flavors. Complement your meal with garlic breadsticks or a refreshing beverage like freshly brewed iced tea or a classic Coke selection to complete the experience.

The dining atmosphere at Tony’s Pizza is warm and inviting, evoking nostalgia mixed with community spirit. The commitment to local support shines through, as noted by guests remembering how Tony’s helped showcase local art, making it much more than just a dinner stop but a gathering place for memorable moments. Reviews echo the deep loyalty and love for this establishment — from Bob Hoyt’s praise of the perfectly thin, buttery crust and generous toppings, to E. Dominic Black’s raving about the Sicilian deep dish that offers incredible value and taste balance.

What truly sets Tony’s Pizza apart is the way it preserves its authentic, handcrafted approach in a fast-paced world — requiring customers to call in and pick up their orders, reminiscent of "the old days." This commitment ensures every pizza leaving their kitchen maintains its integrity and excellence. Long-time patrons like Katie Camarena celebrate how despite changes in ownership, the essence of Tony’s hasn’t wavered, continuing to be a treasured part of their childhood and ongoing pizza adventures.

If you’re searching for a genuine slice of Italy in San Marino, delivered with passion and a personal touch, Tony’s Pizza is a must-visit destination. From the first crispy, buttery crust to the last satisfying chew, your taste buds will thank you—and like many before you, you’ll find yourself coming back again and again.